MIRACULOUS SURVIVAL IN A CAVE: After 7 days without food, Nancy Guthrie is allegedly found drinking water dripping from stalactites — her first words: “Don’t trust…”

Public interest intensified further because of one specific element repeated across multiple versions of the story: Nancy’s alleged first words upon being discovered. According to these online claims, as responders attempted to comfort her, she reportedly whispered just three incomplete words — “Don’t trust…” — before losing consciousness again. The unfinished phrase quickly fueled widespread speculation. Online forums, comment sections, and amateur sleuth communities began dissecting the statement, attempting to interpret its meaning and connect it to family dynamics, previously questioned individuals, or even broader conspiracy theories.