Sources Reveal Latest Developments in Nancy Guthrie Case

She was expected to attend a regular church gathering the following morning but never showed up. When friends and then family members visited her home the next day and found her missing, they called 911 around noon on February 1.

Inside her home, essential personal items including her cellphone, wallet, and car were found undisturbed — unexpected for someone who left voluntarily.

Detectives concluded the situation was inconsistent with a routine missing person’s case and officially declared her home a crime scene.

The Pima County Sheriff’s Department and the FBI have treated the case as a potential abduction, noting that Guthrie — who relied on daily medication and lived with limited mobility — could not have simply walked away from her home on her own.

Surveillance Footage and What It Shows

One of the most startling developments early in the case was the release of doorbell camera footage showing a masked and gloved individual on Guthrie’s front porch in the early morning hours of February 1.