DURING OUR 10TH YEAR ANNIVERSARY DINNER, I STOOD IN FRONT OF PEOPLE WITH A BLACK EYE.

Play it,” she said.

Mark frowned, irritation flashing as confusion set in. “What is this supposed to be?”

Without answering, Emily tapped the screen herself. What followed sliced through the room more sharply than any raised voice. It was Mark—his voice, unmistakable—recorded just two nights earlier.

“She needs to learn respect,” the recording said. “If my sisters scare her a bit, maybe she’ll finally fall in line.”

A wave of gasps spread around the table. Someone whispered, “Oh my God.” Lauren’s grin disappeared. Denise went pale.

Emily didn’t stop. She swiped again and turned the phone so everyone could see—photos of the bruises on my arm from last year, screenshots of messages where Mark threatened to lock our shared account if I didn’t “behave,” all carefully dated and organized. She’d been saving everything for months, ever since she noticed how withdrawn I’d become, how easily I startled when voices rose.

“I asked her to send these to me,” Emily said to the table, her tone firm and controlled. “In case she was ever too scared to speak for herself.”

Mark shot to his feet, his chair scraping loudly against the floor. “This is private,” he snapped. “You have no right—”